I might actually favor the second one, only we'd have to do something about the text. I'm going for a more refined look overall, and the text seems too... blocky. I was also going to ask if we could try for using a color with a white border around it for the Christian Forums large text. And you'd definitely want to center the lower text like you did in the last one, maybe raise it a touch closer to the big text, and possibly try a little cursive to something to again avoid the blocky look. But one eagle offset to the right does seem to be a better look.